Because there are so many brands of squirrel bait out there, it’s easy to get overwhelmed about your options on the best type of squirrel bait.

Here I am going to go over the best squirrel baits to help you get rid of your squirrel problem with confidence. There are many different types of squirrel baits available on the market, but three of them stood out as the best bait for sale:

If You’re Looking for the Best Squirrel Baits in 2019, Look No Further
ProductFeatures
Our #1 Rated
  • Doesn’t dry out
  • Nontoxic formula
  • No foul odor
Check Price
NB Squirrel Bait by WCS previewWCS NB Squirrel & Rodent Paste Bait by Wildlife Control Supplies
People’s Choice
  • Fast and effective
  • Contains bromadiolone
  • Individually wrapped bars
Check Price
Just One Bite II by Farnam previewJust One Bite II Bait Chunks by Farnam
Squirrel Bait by Kaytee previewKaytee Squirrel & Critter Blend Bait
  • Safe and humane
  • Uses grains and seeds
  • Proven effectiveness
Check Price

While having squirrels in your yard may not seem like a serious issue at first, the fact is, squirrels can be a very problematic issue to have. Sure, they may seem small and harmless, but squirrels are not only a nuisance, they can also carry serious diseases (such as the plague) that can harm you, your family, and your pets.

To make matters worse, squirrels are extremely destructive. If they move into your attic or garage, they can cause significant damage to your property. Squirrels tend to chew on everything they see, which means that you could be facing serious issues with them gnawing on electrical cords or other wiring in your home.

One of the best ways to get rid of squirrels is to trap them. By trapping them, you’re able to keep them locked up until animal control services or your local exterminator can come out and retrieve them.

However, it’s not enough to just set out a trap to lure the squirrels in. They are wily animals and can evade regular traps easily. You need to give them a very attractive and appealing bait to help coax them into your traps.

Thorough Review of the Top 5 Best Squirrel Baits on the Market

There are so many different types of squirrel baits for sale, and depending on how you’d like to approach your squirrel issue, you can choose from how you get rid of them. Many people just want their squirrels gone for good and don’t mind exterminating them on their own. Other people, though, would rather not hurt the squirrels and would prefer to have a professional take care of it for them.

Depending on how you would prefer to get rid of your squirrels, you have several different choices on the type of squirrel bait that you decide to use. There is no wrong or right way to get rid of squirrels, and it’s important to remember that if you don’t get rid of them, they will destroy your property and possibly expose you to serious diseases.

If you’ve been on the hunt for the perfect squirrel bait to get rid of your problematic squirrel issue once and for all, you can stop searching now. I’ve gathered up the top 5 squirrel baits and have analyzed their key benefits your convenience.

Of the 5 best squirrel baits on the market right now, one really impressed me as the most superior one available. I came to this conclusion based on how effective, reliable, and dependable it is. This undisputed winner is WCS NB Paste.

 

1. WCS NB Paste – The Very Best Humane, Effective, and Safe Squirrel Bait (Editor’s Choice)

NB Squirrel Bait by WCSView on Amazon

Many people like to use peanut butter on their squirrel traps, but not everyone can handle peanuts due to allergies. Peanut butter also tends to dry out, which means the squirrels will ignore it. If you’re looking for a highly effective and humane formula that works as well as peanut butter but won’t dry out or have dangerous allergens, you will be very happy with WCS NB Paste.

How it Works

Squirrels love nuts and seeds, and it’s easy for them to run up and stuff a bunch into their mouth and skitter off. Using a paste helps prevent that, but the problem with peanut butter is that it can dry out and some people can’t handle it due to allergies. WCS NB Paste helps solve that problem by luring squirrels in without letting them run off before the trap closes.

In-Depth Review

This is a unique product in that it uses a great idea (using peanut butter to trap squirrels) and improves upon it. Unlike other types of squirrel baits, which can risk allowing the squirrel to escape or simply kills them, this one is a safe and non-toxic formula. It is also more effective than peanut butter, since it doesn’t dry out. Even better, it is a product that is aware of the risk of allergic reactions in people and avoids adding any peanut butter to this product.

This product comes in a convenient screw-top container, making removing the desired amount a breeze. Once you’re satisfied with the amount you’ve removed, you can secure the lid back on the jar. That can help prolong the shelf-life of the product and also makes it harder for any animals from getting into the packaging.

What Makes WCS NB Paste a Winner?
The best thing about this product is that it is entirely safe and will not harm any children or pets. You can decide how you want to get rid of the squirrels and won’t accidentally stumble upon any rodent corpses in your humane squirrel trap. Because it works so well and is such a good product, it gets the highest marks from me in this review.

Pros
  • Won’t dry out
  • Doesn’t kill squirrels
  • Nonallergenic (no peanuts)
  • Sturdy packaging
  • No bad scent
Cons
  • Only attracts, doesn’t kill
  • May contain other allergens
 

2. Just One Bite II – The Best Fast-Acting, Effective, and Lethal Squirrel Bait (People’s Choice)

Just One Bite II by FarnamView on Amazon

If you have no problems with killing squirrels and aren’t overly worried about a humane formula, then you won’t be disappointed with Just One Bite II. This product is proven to kill squirrels after their first encounter, which means you won’t have to worry about sick squirrels running around your yard. It’s fast, effective, and lethal, solving all of your squirrel problems in just one dose.

How it Works

Just One Bite II uses a special type of ingredient that has proven to kill squirrels overnight. This ingredient is called bromadiolone, a type of anti-coagulant blood thinner that is lethal to squirrels. The product uses poison-coated nuts and seeds, which are attractive to squirrels, luring them into take a taste. When they consume Just One Bite II, they are immediately poisoned and will run off to die.

In-Depth Review

Just One Bite II comes in a box of eight individually wrapped bars. Each bar weighs one pound each and is made of a combination of nuts and seeds that have bromadiolone in them. The shape of the bars makes it easier for the squirrels to nibble on it, increasing their dose of the poison. They can also be broken into smaller pieces for controlled dosing.

There’s no shame in wanting to kill squirrels, as they are known hazards to gardens, homes, people, and pets. With Just One Bite II, you don’t have to worry about a drawn-out process of waiting for squirrels to die. They will die immediately, solving your problems in just one day. That said, the active ingredient in Just One Bite II is highly dangerous to all animals, but children are especially vulnerable to it. Be sure to keep it away from children and pets. It’s also important to note that this product is not sold in California.

Why Just One Bite II is a Great Product

With its conveniently packaged bars and highly effective formula, I strongly believe that this is a fantastic product to use against any invasive squirrels on your property. You won’t be disappointed when you use it.

Pros
  • Works extremely fast
  • Individually wrapped bars
  • Proven to work
Cons
  • Dangerous to humans and pets
  • Not sold in California
 

3. Kaytee – A Safe, Dependable and Non-Lethal Squirrel Bait

Squirrel Bait by KayteeView on Amazon

Not everyone wants to have to kill their bothersome squirrels. Your reasons are your own, whether you are a soft-hearted person or you simply get squeamish around dead rodents. Regardless, Kaytee’s Squirrel and Critter Blend is exactly what you need to safely and gently coax squirrels into a trap for quick removal. It’s a very safe and harmless product and uses just a combination of seeds, nuts, and grains – a squirrel’s favorite foods – to help capture them.

How it Works
Squirrels are foragers by nature and are always looking for an easy meal. Katyee’s gives them that by bribing them into your trap with their favorite treats. The squirrels are naturally very attracted to these foods, which are part of their normal diet, and will wander into the trap to get at it.

In-Depth Review

Kaytee’s Squirrel and Critter blend was originally designed to feed squirrels and keep them out of bird feeders. Then enterprising consumers like yourself realized this makes an excellent bait for trapping squirrels, and the rest is history.

Kaytee comes in a heavy-duty woven plastic bag, which means that it won’t split or tear when you’re using it. Furthermore, there is no bulky, wasteful packing involved. That makes storage a breeze when you’re not using it. The product consists of small bits of squirrel food, which means that it’s not toxic or dangers. You don’t have to be worried about accidentally harming your children or pets when you use Kaytee.

What’s the Final Word on Kaytee?

You really can’t go wrong with Kaytee. With its sturdy packaging and non-toxic formula, this product has been shown to work and will help you get rid of your squirrels without worrying about harming them.

Pros
  • Proven to work
  • Uses nontoxic ingredients
  • Durable, minimalist packaging
  • Won’t harm any squirrels
Cons
  • Doesn’t actually kill squirrels
  • Package only comes in one size
 

4. KAPUT – A Highly Deadly Squirrel Bait that Also Kills Fleas

Kaput Squirrel BaitView on Amazon

When you have a squirrel problem, your problem doesn’t stop with the squirrels. It also means you have to deal with the disease-carrying fleas on their bodies. Of all of the squirrel baits that I’m reviewing, this is the only one that takes this flea problem into consideration. After all, just because you kill a squirrel doesn’t mean that the fleas will die too. KAPUT Bait solves this problem for you.

How it Works
KAPUT Bait uses two main active ingredients in its formula, as well as oat groats to attract the squirrel. First, it has diphacinone, a powerful anti-coagulant that swiftly kills any squirrels that consumes it. Next, it contains imidacloprid, a type of insect neurotoxin that wipes out any fleas that are left remaining on the squirrel. Together, it makes a very good product that helps solve your squirrel problems on two fronts.

In-Depth Review

Everyone knows that when you have squirrels, you’re also at the risk of encountering their fleas. KAPUT Bait knows this and has designed their product to help treat all aspects of a squirrel infestation. Its three main ingredients are diphacinone, imidacloprid, and oat groats. This combination of ingredients kills the squirrel, its fleas, and does so in a manner that helps make sure the squirrel will actually eat the bait. These ingredients make for a very convenient product and can solve all of your squirrel problems in just one step.

KAPUT Bait comes in a heavy-duty plastic bucket, which means that it’s easy to get the desired portion out. Once you have the amount you want, you can seal it back up for further storage. There’s minimal risk of spillage, and the air-tight container means that curious animals can’t get into it without your knowledge. This product comes in a small pellet shape, similar to a grain of rice.

Is There Anything Else You Need to Know?

You need to be careful when handling this product, as it does contain toxic ingredients. Make sure you wear gloves when using it, and use it at least 100 yards away from all buildings. KAPUT bait is legal to use in the state of California, too, as well as all other states that might otherwise prohibit the product.

Pros
  • Kills squirrels and their fleas
  • Heavy duty packaging
  • Legal to use in all states
Cons
  • Can’t be used near buildings
  • Can be harmful to humans and pets
 

5. Ramik Lure – A Very Dependable and Non-Toxic Squirrel Attractant for Live Animal Traps

Squirrel Lure by RamikView on Amazon

If you’re wanting to use a live trap to capture your squirrels, then you can be assured that even the pickiest squirrels will be interested in Ramik Lure. This is a safe, non-toxic product that uses only food grade ingredients to attract unwanted squirrels, allowing you to capture them for easy removal from your property.

How it Works

Squirrels can be choosy animals, especially if they have a wide selection of food to choose from in your yard. You want a product that is even more attractive than your garden or your home’s wiring to the squirrels. Ramik Lure uses 100% food-safe ingredients that are proven to draw the squirrel in, encouraging it to pick the lure over other offerings. When combined with actual food products (like apple slices), it makes a completely irresistible squirrel bait.

In-Depth Review

Not all squirrel baits understand how cautious some squirrels can be. While most products make claims that they’ll catch the squirrel without any hesitation, this product admits that it works best when used alongside fresh produce. This shows that the company understands how squirrels think and that Ramik Lure was created with that knowledge in mind.

Ramik Lure comes in a sturdy screw-top container, which means that you can take out exactly the portion you want. It uses small pellets to attract the squirrels. The remaining stays in the tub, out of the reach of air and other foraging animals. You can store the remaining, unused portion in a dry place until needed again.

Should You Use Ramik Lure?
This product is safe to use around children and pets, and you don’t need to use gloves to handle it. While it is not safe for you to eat, you don’t have to panic if you accidentally touch it. It also means that you can use it in and around your home or in your basement, garage, or attic without fear. All in all, this is a safe and very good squirrel bait.
Pros
  • Completely safe to use
  • Sturdy packaging
  • Very attractive to squirrels
Cons
  • Nonlethal formula
  • May not work as well on its own

What is the Best Squirrel Bait in November, 2019? – Comprehensive Buyer’s Guide

Choosing the right kind of squirrel bait for your infestation can very stressful. After all, nobody wants to accidentally choose the wrong type of bait.

I understand how important it is to you to have a trustworthy and reliable squirrel bait to help eliminate your squirrel problems. That is why I have taken the time to carefully review the best and most powerful squirrel baits available for you.

In this buyer’s guide, I will analyze all aspects of these squirrel baits to help you make an educated and informed decision that you can feel good about.

Do These Squirrel Baits Work?

Consumers like yourself have many questions they are facing when they are looking to purchase squirrel bait. What they want to know is if the product is actually going to attract the squirrel or if the squirrel will just ignore it for other foods.

How can you know you’re choosing a good product?

Here’s what I’ve focused on in this review:

  • Each product that I have reviewed is proven to work.
  • The baits use proven attractants to lure in the squirrels.
  • The squirrel will be drawn to the trap and won’t ignore it.
  • You can then decide what you want to do with your captured squirrel.

Your satisfaction with your squirrel bait is very important, which is why I’ve chosen these products for review.

What is the Fate of the Squirrel?

Another huge consideration that shoppers face is if the squirrel bait is going to kill or harm the squirrel or if it can be used in a live trap.

I have made sure that each review shares these details with you so you can make a choice that best matches your morals. Not everyone feels good about killing animals themselves.

There are four important questions to ask yourself when choosing a lethal or a non-lethal squirrel bait.

  1. Will the squirrel die after eating the bait?
  2. If it dies, will it suffer, or will it be merciful?
  3. Will I have to deal with a sick or dying squirrel myself?
  4. Does the squirrel know if the bait is toxic or not?

These products do not prolong suffering of the squirrel, so you can feel good about buying them. If they are toxic, they kill fast and mercifully. Regardless of what’s in them, they will draw the squirrel into the trap for capture.

What Ingredients are Used in These Squirrel Baits?

Informed consumers want to know what ingredients are in the squirrel bait. After all, you have a right to know what’s in a product you are purchasing.

These squirrel baits use ingredients that are both attractive and tasty to squirrels, such as:

  • Nuts,
  • Seeds,
  • Grains,
  • Flavorings.

In addition to these natural ingredients, some also contain toxic ingredients (such as anti-coagulants) which will kill the squirrel. The product you choose will determine if the outcome for the squirrel.

What Form Does the Bait Come In?

Finally, cautious shoppers want to know exactly what they’re getting when they choose their squirrel bait. This information will help them make the right choice.

These squirrel baits come in many different shapes and styles, including:

  • Granules,
  • Bars,
  • Pastes,
  • Natural.

Each has its own benefits and advantages for use, giving you a variety of options to choose from. I have made sure to explain what form each bait comes in, so you can be confident that you are making the right choice for your squirrel trap.

Conclusion: Getting Rid of Your Squirrel Problem

Squirrels on your property are neither cute nor safe.

They can quickly put your home, garden, and even family and pets in danger with their presence. When you have a squirrel problem on your hands, you don’t want to mess around with messy and useless squirrel baits that don’t work.

No matter the scope of your squirrel infestation, you’ll want a squirrel bait that works. I’ve chosen products across a wide range of formats, ranging from non-toxic pastes to fast-acting and lethal bars. Depending on what you’re looking for, you can be assured you’re going to choose the right squirrel bait when you pick one of these.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for dependable and reliable squirrel bait, you’ll find something that works well for you here. You really can’t go wrong with the WCS NB Paste, because it’s safe, reliable, and proven to work. However, any of the products covered in this review will give you the results you need.

Before you know it, your squirrel problems will be a distant memory, allowing you to enjoy your home without their unwanted presence any longer!

You can find further details of Squirrels Control here.